Test Lists

  • Regression Package Testing List Page
Publisher QA3 - UPP Test
  • Regression Package Testing List Page
1 / 0

Here’s what Brett Kavanaugh said on CNN about Bush v. Gore in 2000

October 27, 2020
By Devan Cole, CNN
Georgia Breaks Turnout Record For First Day Of Early Voting
Ben Gray - member online, Atlanta Journal-Constitution
People wait in line to vote in Decatur, Ga., Monday, Oct. 12, 2020.
Share this...
  • Facebook
  • Pinterest
  • Twitter
  • Linkedin

Nearly two decades before Brett Kavanaugh was appointed to the Supreme Court, he helped with George W. Bush’s legal fight before the court in the contested 2000 presidential election, providing insight at the time into his view on questions of whether the Constitution allows state courts to tinker with election rules.

The comments from Kavanaugh, who at the time was working as a private lawyer, to CNN’s Wolf Blitzer in December 2000 are notable given speculation by both Democrats and Republicans that the high court might again have to settle election disputes following next week’s presidential contest.

The justice himself set the battle lines for how the court should consider post-election lawsuits that could determine the outcome of the presidential race in a footnote of a concurring opinion he issued Monday in an election-related case, referencing the highly consequential Bush v. Gore case he worked on 20 years ago.

Speaking to Blitzer outside the Supreme Court in 2000, Kavanaugh dismissed a question about political differences, saying, “I think you’re focusing on the wrong issue there. The real issue is what does Article II of the Constitution mean in the first instance. And it delegates authority directly to the state legislatures. And the textualists on the court, led by Justice (Antonin) Scalia, are paying close attention to that language.”

“And I think what we’re seeing is more of a divide over how to interpret the Constitution than really political differences. I don’t think the justices care that it’s Bush v. Gore or if it were Gore v. Bush,” he said in the interview, which came after the justices had heard oral arguments but before they ruled. “What they care about is how to interpret the Constitution — what are the enduring values that are going to stand a generation from now?”

Speculating about the reaction of Justice Anthony Kennedy and other members, Kavanaugh said he thought they were concerned about “whether the Florida Supreme Court had so departed from the election code previously established by the legislature that it had violated the United States Constitution, which after all delegates the power to the legislatures of the states.”

The Supreme Court would eventually halt the Florida recounts, declaring that county standards for assessing the intentions of voters on disputed ballots varied too widely to be fair. The court said the variations violated the 14th Amendment’s equal protection guarantee.

The comments from the future justice and his concurring opinion on Monday will no doubt loom in the background with just a week to go until Election Day, and as the justices consider several petitions before them concerning election rules.

“Under the U.S. Constitution, the state courts do not have a blank check to rewrite state election laws for federal elections,” Kavanaugh wrote Monday.

He went on to mention the 2000 case, picking up on the reasoning of then-Chief Justice William Rehnquist in a concurrence that only garnered the votes of two other justices — Scalia and Justice Clarence Thomas.

“The text of Article II means that the ‘clearly expressed intent of the legislature must prevail’ and that a state court may not depart from the state election code enacted by the legislature,” Kavanaugh wrote.

CNN’s Ariane de Vogue and Joan Biskupic contributed to this report.

Categories: Madison Magazine Logo

Latest Stories

Eu Regulator Authorizes Astrazeneca Vaccine For All Adults

EU regulator authorizes AstraZeneca vaccine for all adults

Rayos Syndication User,
KXLY-Latest Stories

Regulators authorized AstraZeneca’s coronavirus vaccine for use in adults throughout the European Union on Friday, amid criticism the bloc is not moving fast enough to vaccinate its population.

Ex Fbi Lawyer Given Probation For Russia Probe Actions

Ex-FBI lawyer given probation for Russia probe actions

Rayos Syndication User,
KXLY-Latest Stories

WASHINGTON (AP) — A former FBI lawyer was sentenced to probation for altering an email that the Justice Department relied on during its surveillance of an aide to President Donald Trump during the Russia investigation.

Evers: Repealing Mask Mandate Like Eliminating Speed Limits

Evers: Repealing mask mandate like eliminating speed limits

Rayos Syndication User,
KXLY-Latest Stories

MADISON, Wis. (AP) — Democratic Gov. Tony Evers lashed out Friday at rival Republicans who tried to repeal his statewide mask mandate, saying killing the order would be a ridiculous move comparable to abolishing speed limits.

Conservatives Praise South Carolina Win On Abortion Ban

Conservatives praise South Carolina win on abortion ban

Rayos Syndication User,
KXLY-Latest Stories

COLUMBIA, S.C. (AP) — As some conservatives in South Carolina celebrated getting a bill that would ban almost all abortions in the state past a legislative barrier and likely becoming law, they said they are not finished trying to end all abortions.

Moscow Court Puts Navalny’s Allies Under House Arrest

Moscow court puts Navalny's allies under house arrest

Rayos Syndication User,
KXLY-Latest Stories

A Moscow court on Friday put the brother and several allies of Russian opposition leader Alexei Navalny under house arrest for two months as authorities sought to stymie more protests over the jailing of the top Kremlin foe.

Most Popular

9:40 Future Import Test

One more current test NW

Current UPP Import NW

Test New Article 12092025 - 4 - Message

Test New Article 12092025 - 4 - Election

Test New Article 12092025 - 2 - Closing

© 2026 Publisher QA3 – UPP Test.

Privacy Policy
Powered byBLOX Digital
X